Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Huge Slice Of Cheese 1/4 Of 20" Pie
SIDE OF RANCH
Hawaiian Lovers Pizza XL Large 20"
Hawaiian Lovers Pizza MEDIUM 14" Inch
About
New York Pizza Company
Introducing New York Pizza Company: A Slice of Authenticity in Louisville
At the New York Pizza Company, located at 2354 Frankfort Ave, Louisville, KY 40206, pizza lovers can enjoy a taste of the Big Apple right in their own backyard. This local gem specializes in authentic New York-style pizza, offering a variety of gourmet options that thrill the senses and satisfy cravings.
Highlights of the Menu
- Huge Slices: Get your appetite ready for a HUGE Slice of Cheese or a HUGE Slice of Pepperoni, both enormous 1/4 slices of a 20" pie for just US$6.99.
- Specialty Pies: Feast on a traditional Pizza Margherita XL, featuring fresh tomatoes, basil, and premium ingredients all layered on a perfectly baked thin crust for only US$35.99.
- Beer Garden: Pair your pizza with a refreshing drink. Choose from a selection of beers including Modelo Especial and Yuengling for just US$4.45.
The dough is freshly made daily, using premium ingredients like Italian mozzarella and fresh tomato sauce, all baked in a deck oven for that classic crunch. Customers rave about the light and fresh nature of the pizzas, eliminating any worries of greasy leftovers!
What truly sets New York Pizza Company apart are the glowing reviews from satisfied patrons. “The pizza is very good and fresh!”, says Erin Smith, praising both the cheese and pepperoni varieties. Meanwhile, Bri Robles notes, “Best pizza I’ve had in Louisville,” highlighting the unique flavors like Jamaican Jerk chicken alongside the delicious crust.
It's not just the pizza that creates a buzz; the warm hospitality and inviting ambiance keep customers coming back. Samantha Dore’s experience reveals the owner’s commitment to service, as he graciously accommodated her while she waited with her pup on the patio, confirming that this could be your go-to spot for good food and good company.
Even those seasoned in the art of pizza making, like Joseph Turner, commend the New York Pizza Company for its authenticity. He states, “The crust is crispy but airy,” affirming that it meets the high standards of New York pizza aficionados.
In a city where pizza options are plentiful yet varied, New York Pizza Company stands out with its dedication to quality and authenticity. Whether you're seated at their inviting patio or enjoying a slice delivered to your door, you're in for a delightful pizza experience that transports you straight to New York City.
So grab your friends, share a slice or two, and taste the magic of New York pizza right here in Louisville.
Contact: For orders, you can reach them at +1 502-963-5756.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Pizza is very good and fresh! I've tried the pepperoni and cheese pizza, and they are both amazing. The cheese pizza is very light weight and not greasy. Got a whole cheese pie and 2 drinks for 30! Every whole pizza is made ready to order, hot and fresh. You can also order by the slice and you get 2 big slices. ”
“ Best pizza I’ve had in Louisville. We bought slices of the Jamaican Jerk chicken, cheese, and meat pie. The dough was so delicious and the service was quick. Can’t wait to go back again ”
“ Stopped in and had to wait a bit (no biggie!) but had my pup in the car, owner let us sit on the patio AND brought everything out when it was ready, even though he was slammed! Slices were perfection. Been chasing the perfect new York slice here in Louisville for a while and this was it!! Will be back to enjoy the patio soon! ”
“ Nice little pizza joint. Stopped here while on a college visit with my daughter. The pizza was amazing. The facility was clean and had a 100% A grade from the local health department. Owner was super nice and friendly. My family and I will definitely visit this place again. ”
“ As an east coast transplant, I've been looking for good NY style pizza in Louisville for a DECADE, and NY Pizza Company is a godsend. If you are tired of Louisville pizza, which is by and large doughy garbage, then this place is for you. I've only ordered delivery so I can't speak to the in-person experience. The slices are big and the crust is crispy but airy. I'm not a big fan of their grandma style but the NY style is legit. ”
“ Hands down the best pie in KY! Greeted as soon as we walked into the door with a smiling face. Was given a rundown of what they had to offer and ordered without needing a menu. Nice simple place to eat extraordinarily good pie! This will definitely be our go to for pizza night! ”
“ Brought the New Yorkers to town and they said this is NY Pizza. Great place to order by 1/8 pie (which is a slice), 1/4 pie which is big, and full pies. Order at the counter and line can get long and slow due to dine-ins, takeouts / DoorDash, but worth the wait. Indoor and outdoor seating. For a tasty NY slice in Louisville, this is the place. ”
“ This is just a small place but the pizza is amazing. Authentic NY style and the slices are huge. Not much other then pizza served but the pizza is so good I didn't miss other menu items. Owner is friendly and seems to care about the quality of the food and cleanliness of the restaurant. We will be back! ”